Englisch-As gesucht!
Folgende Analyse muss ich morgen abgeben......und etliche Formulierungen sind meiner Meinung nach noch üüüüüübelst deutsch..
Ist unter Euch vll ein Englisch-As, das auf Anhieb den ein oder anderen schwerwiegenden.......ekelhaft en Missbrauch der englischen Sprache ausfindig machen könnte?
Wäre mehr als toll....
Gruß,
Sonja
The Rose
Some say love it is a river
That drowns the tender reed.
Some say love it is a razor
That leaves your soul to bleed.
Some say love it is a hunger
An endless, aching need
I say love it is a flower,
And you it[']s only seed.
It's the heart afraid of breaking
That never learns to dance
It's the dream afraid of waking
That never takes the chance
It's the one who won't be taken,
Who cannot seem to give
And the soul afraid of dying
That never learns to live.
And the night has been too lonely
And the road has been too long.
And you think that love is only
For the lucky and the strong.
Just remember in the winter
Far beneath the bitter snow
Lies the seed that with the sun's love,
In the spring, becomes a rose.
http://www.bbbs.ch/ie2/ly [...] rose.txt
General subject of the rose
In the poem “the rose”, written by Amanda McBroom, two very different views of love are compared. On the one hand, there are the people who have a very discouraging and pessimistic opinion about love and on the other hand, there is the orator, who still believes in love and who tries to encourage these people to lose their fear and really get involved in love.
The two different views of love compared in the poem – a brief summary
The people who are only able to see the negative sides of love seem to have had experiences with love that deeply hurt them (In view of the first and the third unit I would exclude that they only heard about it.)
Evidence for this might be the metaphors of the river, the razor, and the hunger in the first unit, which seem to illustrate quite well what these people suffered. The orator lets us know that they might had been “too lonely” (l.17) and “the[ir] road ha[d] been too long” (l.18) and that they apparently no longer believe in love. These facts make us sympathize with them and understand why they are so afraid of getting involved with a new person again. They also allow us to comprehend what their fears are.
Understanding the fears of these people very well, the orator tries to show them that love is not like that when they succeed in overcoming their fears and really get involved with a person. He says that they must not think about the consequences when they do something which could make them happy because they fear these possible consequences. He points out that they neither can be happy, learn to
ANführungsstriche!
dance nor will ever be taken, if they live ruled by their fears and do not tear down their self-built walls. He tries to encourage and give them hope by telling them that there currently might be very dark and hard times for them but that it behaves quite in the same way as the seed. He calls them the love’s only seed which in the “spring, becomes a rose” in order to show them that they have to wait until their time is to come, a bright time, that comes up after the dark, as the flower. (l. 7)
Focal points of analysis (Analyseschwerpunkte??!?)
During the course of my thesis, I will now point out, through an exact analysis of the images that entirely carry this poem, the different views of love. I especially would like to elaborate on the mode of action of the images (Wirkungsweise?!?!) and the reasons for the fears of people who don't believe in love anymore.
Structure and title
The poem is composed of six stanzas of four lines each and can be divided into three sub-units, each of them containing two stanzas.
The first conclusions of the poem’s content can immediately be drawn from its title. The rose is a very common symbol of love, and in the run of the poem it will become obviously clear that the rose is to be equated with love here.
The first unit
The first unit of the poem directly takes up the motif of love. Here the orator, who is first person singular, compares the quite pessimistic opinion of love of the others represented by “some” (lines 1, 3, 5) and later by “you” (line 8) to his much more optimistic and hopeful view.
The accumulation of negative arguments is stressed by the extremely striking use of the combination of anaphoras, parallelisms and the rhyme schemata. In lines one to four the speaker describes how the others see love. He says that some see love as “a river, that drowns the tender reed” (ll. 1-2) and as “a razor, that leaves [the] soul to bleed” (ll.3-4). These two metaphors which are linked through the utilization of parallelisms and anaphoras (lines one and three, the other in lines two and four) and the rhyme in lines two and four illustrate the fear of these people in a very urgent way, because a rapid river, just as a razor, can hurt or even cause death.
The very violent imagery of the river which drowns the tender reed shows that even love is able to drown something, and to carry someone away with it.
Sometimes, people jump into a relationship without really knowing each other first. One of them adapts his/her lifestyle too much to that of his potential lover without really being ready for a relationship, or they may speak too quickly about strong feelings for each other. Then they will perhaps have to realize in the end, that love, nearness and affection were only an illusion and wishful thinking.
But, even worse is when one of the lovers has developed deep feelings for his partner during this time. The other person, however, noticed that their own feelings were not of the same intensity, and were only for a very short, even though intensive, period. Often such unanswered feelings lead into a crisis, perhaps even depression. Sometimes there are people who feel uprooted and unloved after such a split, and so filled with self-doubt and hurt feelings that they are afraid of getting involved with another person again. They fear that a new relationship could possibly take the same course and the same wounds would be inflicted upon their hearts again. A very famous saying says: “Who loves, is easy to hurt”. This is exactly what is meant by the tender reed - a person that loves another person is, to a certain extent, dependent on this person and at her mercy because when you love someone he has the ability to hurt you very badly.
The metaphor of “the razor that leaves [the] soul to bleed” (ll.3-4) refers to exactly these wounds and works according to the same schemata. Love is described here as a very hard and sharp tool that is able to cause deep flesh wounds and which is sometimes misused for self-abuse, a silent cry for help of people who do not know how to go on with life, who have fears with which they can’t cope, perhaps, even are not able to feel that they are alive.
This image of the razor, which is closely related to that one of the rapid as well in its message as in its syntax (parallelism, anaphora), is to show again how much love can hurt and how serious the wounds of it can be. The soul (l.4) stands here for the whole person (pars pro toto) or, spoken in a more romantic way, for the heart. The heart, like the rose, is a very common symbol of love and it has become common to think of the heart as the home of the soul, of love and feelings. Biologically seen is the heart one of the most important organs of a human being and it would in, all probability, mean a person's death, if the heart was harmed. This means that it could be a person’s physical or even mental death if he/she was hurt by love in such a violent way.
Furthermore, the idea of misuse of a razor raises the question of whether love could be some kind of self-abuse. People who scratch themselves usually feel good while they hurt themselves with a razor - they find an outlet in this action and feel alive while they scratch their body and see the blood, but then, after a while, things are worse then before. They did not help them to escape reality - their escape was only temporary and after the kick they got out of cutting themselves, the problems are even worse and what remains are the wounds and in the long run the scars. So these people may see love as some sort of self-abuse, an action with which to find a way out of reality, fears and pain; a state which seems to be pleasant stunning and comforting for a short time, but when it is over the situation became worse than before and what remains are the scars on their soul, which will never fade completely.
The second stanza is connected with the preceding one by the continued use of anaphora, parallelism and by the retained motive of danger.
Here the opinion of “some” is again represented in the form of the parallelism (some say love it is a hunger, line 5) but then in the second part of the parallelism there is a very important turning point because here the narrator for the first time, presents his opinion (ll.7/8; I say love it is a flower, and you its only seed) in contrast to the view of “some”.
The metaphor of hunger in this stanza works according to the same principle as that of the river and the razor and also illustrates that love can harm a person.
In this image, love is compared with hunger which is a basic need in order to show that one can hunger for love as well as one can hunger for food and that it makes no difference if this hunger is physical or psychological.
SEHNSUCHT
The fact that in the world there are millions of people who die because they do not have enough to eat and every child knows that a being has to eat if it wants to stay alive is to prove how serious and elementary this hunger of love to this people is and that they think every being is damned to die sooner or later if it does not get enough love.
Furthermore, the hopelessness of the people becomes quiet clear in this metaphor because here it says that they believe that this hunger is “endless and aching”. Especially the expression “endless” makes the reader feel that these people really do not seem to have kept any hope and do not believe in better times to come. The use of “aching” is in my opinion used in order to stress, that this mental hurt even affected to their body.
The orators view of love
After this representation of the others’ view of love a great “BUT” seems to follow and the orator tells about his own attitude towards love, which marks a very important turning point of the poem.
He claims that love is a flower (l. 7) and that the people are its only seed (l.8). By the utilization of this metaphor he tries to give them hope and show them that love is not as cruel as they think. He claims that it is, instead, a very beautiful plant which can grow out of them, and only out of them, because there is no other seed. Due to the fact that the author, in this third line of the second stanza, still keeps the parallelism but gets rid of the anaphora by replacing “some” against “I” he stresses the discrepancy between these two contradictory opinions. It also indicates that he will not change his opinion and stop believing in love.
Furthermore in this line he uses the direct address “you” instead of “some” for the first time in order to involve the audience more forcefully.
The second unit
After introducing the two quite different views of love in the first unit, in the second one the speaker tries to show the people that there will indeed be no fulfilling love for them unless they radically change their way of acting and thinking. In this unit he directly names the various ways of fearful acting and thinking which lead to the point where one can neither receive nor give any love. By the use of many personifications (three of the four reasons given in the third and fourth stanza work with the help of it) the orator tries to show the people in a very urgent way, what exactly they did or still do wrong.
By the means of these examples he tries to make it clear to the people why they are scared and to encourage them to lose these fears and to dare something.
Firstly the orator states the personification of the “heart afraid of breaking” (l. 9), that never learns to dance (l.10). This personification says that those people who are afraid that something could happen to their heart will never love a person so deeply that their heart joyfully in such a fast way that it would nearly start to dance or even give them a heart attack (?????).
In its more figurative and true sense of the word, it says that a person must not be afraid of hurt if he/she really wants to live. Of course one would in, all probability, never be hurt if he never dared anything, but one would also never be able to enjoy and to live. In addition to that, it would be a life full of doubts and fears in which one would never be able to realize his dreams. The following causes are very similar to this first one.
The second personification refers to those very dreams (It’s the dream afraid of waking that never takes the chance, ll.11/12) and is, through its semantics as well as its syntax, connected to the first personification, which serves to show how varied these fears are. This personification appeals to people to fight for their dreams and not to resign because those dreams may appear as inaccessible or hard to reach. It tells people, just as two famous sayings do, to live their dreams and not just to dream their lives, because one who fights can lose, but one who gave up has already lost.
The next stanza is by a further reason connected to the former one but now the order of reason and from this reason resulting consequence (The heart is afraid of breaking and will because of this reason never learn to dance, the dream is afraid waking and will therefore never take the chance…) is altered in order to keep the number of syllables in the poem.
The orator starts this stanza with a statement that does not really need to be analyzed because its message is quite clear.
The statement is that “the one who cannot seem to give” (l.14) won’t be taken (l.13) which means that one must be willing to give something and to accept his person opposite with all her major and minor mistakes if oneself wants to be taken which is an integral fact of love.
The second reason given in this stanza is again a personification and carries more content which can be analyzed.
The orator here claims that the soul which is afraid of dying will never learn to live (ll.15/16).
This statement is closely related to a statement of the bible which contains the order to intrepid creed. (???! furchtlosem Glaubensbekenntnis)
Matthew 10:39 says:
“39Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.”
His further verses all together contain nearly the same content which meaning is that the people must not be scared. Matthew calls upon mankind to believe in god and his love, he tells them to believe in God and not to fear the consequences of their belief as well as the poem calls upon the people to lose their fear and to believe in love.
As well as the heart (l.9), the soul represents the feelings of a being which are equated with the being itself here but is in contrast to this completely non physical. The soul does not need a worldly body because she does only exist of feelings or a material, which we human beings are not able to understand. And this fact, that mankind is not able to comprehend what this material could be, where to the soul will go after death and that the soul might perhaps be eternal, makes us human beings to consider it as something that is to a certain extend divine or at least nearer to something, which is divine and out of our reach. In view of these reasons and the preceding lines by Matthew I would say, that the orator to a certain extend canonizes love.
By these mentioned causes the orator tries to prove the that the people are afraid of committing themselves because they are afraid of being hurt but that they have to lose these fears if they really want to live (l.16), dance (l. 10), being taken (l. 13) and when they want to be able to take the chance. (l. 12)
The second unit is closed by the parallelism “that never learns to live” (l. 16) which has got the same syntax as the last line of the preceding stanza (that never takes the chance, l. 12)
The third unit
The third unit contrasts with the first and the second one because here the poetic stops comparing his opinion with the one of the others and to give them the reasons for their, what he believes, wrong attitude towards love.
The third unit solely pursues the aim to encourage the people not to give up hope for better times to come and not to stop believing in love.
The first two lines of this last unit are linked by the use of anaphora and parallelism and contain the same message.
The orator says here “and the night has been too lonely (l. 17) and the road has been too long” (l.18) in order to show that he understands how hard life for these people must have been in the last time and that he knows, what they must have been suffered.
The image of the lonely night associates darkness, cold and loneliness. Many people are afraid of being alone at night outdoors (or even indoors!) because they fear the dark and the fact, that they cannot see the dangers, which might lurk in this dark. And even if there is no danger, darkness often plays tricks on human beings because of their fantasy that makes them see the various threats. These people might not see these imaginative threats anymore, if there was someone by their side, someone, who would try to fight against their fears and who would give them support and safety.
And in addition to that they would in all probability be able to lose their fears for the real existing dangers, too, if this someone was a person in whom they could completely trust and from whom they would know, that he would never ever let them down and who would always try everything to protect them.
So all in all this image is to underline, how lonely these people were and how much they were on their fear’s mercy, because there was nobody to lean on, a person, who went through the dark times with them. Furthermore it could also show that a relationship can only last, when there is total trust in the partner.
The image of the road, which has been to long (l. 18) stresses, that these times of fear and loneliness lasted on much too long and that it was hard to survive these times, which sapped their energy as well as they sapped their belief in love and their hope for better times.
The next two lines do again start with “and” which stresses, how many things made this time a hard time. The orator supposes here, that the people now “think that love is only for the lucky and the strong” (ll. 19/20). Looking at the past, this would mean, that there would probably never be a further chance for a fulfilling love for these people again because they became weak during the time of the “lonely night” (l. 17). I think that these people saw a lot of happy couples, in which the partners seemed to be very strong but that they perhaps did not realize, that these happiness and strength did also not exist from the very beginning. These relationships also had to develop and these people had to go through very hard times,too, before they found each other and it was a long way and hard work, to built up a relationship, in which both were able to be happy and strong.
Of course it is true that a person that is strong, happy and self-confident is more attractive than a weak person, who only lives in fear and thinks, that there will never be a person, that will truly love him/her but this is the point, which the orator tries to explain in the whole poem. He encourages the people to lose their fears in order to become such a person, that can be loved. So these lines stress again, that it depends on the people themselves, if there will be loved anytime and that it lies in their own responsibility mainly and does not depend on a relationship, whether they become strong or not.
In contrast to the preceding units the two stanzas of the last unit are syntactically and partly semantically not connected to each other.
This serves to put emphasis on the discrepancy, what these people think on the one hand and the hope the orator tries to give them on the other hand, through which a great “BUT” again seems to seperate these two stanzas and by this the two different attitudes.
Furthermore all four lines of this last stanza belong together whereas in the preceding ones it were maximum two that did not make any sense without each other.
These last four lines which are full of metaphorical words, are the part of the poem, in which the intention of the orator to encourage the people becomes mostly clear. The orator appeals to his audience to “remember in the winter (l. 21) “far beneath the bitter snow” (l. 22), that there “lies the seed that with the sun’s love” (l. 23) “in the spring, becomes a rose” (l.24).
The winter here again stands as well as the “lonely night” for the lonely, cold and hard times, which one had to suffer but everybody knows, that there will be a new morning after the night as well as there will be a new spring after the winter again.
It is common to speak about the winter and even the autumn as the seasons of fading life and dead, but it is also common to think that a being that survived the hard winter and succeeded in reaching the next spring will receive new energies and joy of life out of this.
The snow here is to be equated with the bad experiences and the self-isolation that resulted from this experiences of those people, who were badly hurt. This cool surface protects them from new wounds, until they digested it to a sufficient extend as well as the snow protects the seed from the frost. This bitter snow will thaw with the sun’s love in the spring as well as the self-isolation will fade, when the hurt person finishes with the past and gets to know a person, in whom he/she can totally trust and who gives him/her all his/her warmth and love.
The fact that a grain generally contains nearly the whole material which is needed to become a rose serves to show, that everybody of us carries the possibility in himself to become such a rose, a person that grows in the love to another person.
The only difficulty is that we in contrast to the seed are able to melt this snow, which represents our self-isolation.
We alone have to do this, we have to overcome things which happened but which we cannot change after the event if we want to be loved again.
For a person can love one as much as he/she wants, when this person is not ready for this it will not succeed, as well as the sunbeams will never reach the seed, if the snow surface is to thick.
It is important to have line 23 and 24 of the poem to understand line 21 and 22 as well as it is important to know, that this temporary self-isolation helps one to get ready for a new love, that will surely come, when one survived the hard times.
[/the][/the][/d][/ir][/']
Ist unter Euch vll ein Englisch-As, das auf Anhieb den ein oder anderen schwerwiegenden.......ekelhaft en Missbrauch der englischen Sprache ausfindig machen könnte?
Wäre mehr als toll....
Gruß,
Sonja
The Rose
Some say love it is a river
That drowns the tender reed.
Some say love it is a razor
That leaves your soul to bleed.
Some say love it is a hunger
An endless, aching need
I say love it is a flower,
And you it[']s only seed.
It's the heart afraid of breaking
That never learns to dance
It's the dream afraid of waking
That never takes the chance
It's the one who won't be taken,
Who cannot seem to give
And the soul afraid of dying
That never learns to live.
And the night has been too lonely
And the road has been too long.
And you think that love is only
For the lucky and the strong.
Just remember in the winter
Far beneath the bitter snow
Lies the seed that with the sun's love,
In the spring, becomes a rose.
http://www.bbbs.ch/ie2/ly [...] rose.txt
General subject of the rose
In the poem “the rose”, written by Amanda McBroom, two very different views of love are compared. On the one hand, there are the people who have a very discouraging and pessimistic opinion about love and on the other hand, there is the orator, who still believes in love and who tries to encourage these people to lose their fear and really get involved in love.
The two different views of love compared in the poem – a brief summary
The people who are only able to see the negative sides of love seem to have had experiences with love that deeply hurt them (In view of the first and the third unit I would exclude that they only heard about it.)
Evidence for this might be the metaphors of the river, the razor, and the hunger in the first unit, which seem to illustrate quite well what these people suffered. The orator lets us know that they might had been “too lonely” (l.17) and “the[ir] road ha[d] been too long” (l.18) and that they apparently no longer believe in love. These facts make us sympathize with them and understand why they are so afraid of getting involved with a new person again. They also allow us to comprehend what their fears are.
Understanding the fears of these people very well, the orator tries to show them that love is not like that when they succeed in overcoming their fears and really get involved with a person. He says that they must not think about the consequences when they do something which could make them happy because they fear these possible consequences. He points out that they neither can be happy, learn to
ANführungsstriche!
dance nor will ever be taken, if they live ruled by their fears and do not tear down their self-built walls. He tries to encourage and give them hope by telling them that there currently might be very dark and hard times for them but that it behaves quite in the same way as the seed. He calls them the love’s only seed which in the “spring, becomes a rose” in order to show them that they have to wait until their time is to come, a bright time, that comes up after the dark, as the flower. (l. 7)
Focal points of analysis (Analyseschwerpunkte??!?)
During the course of my thesis, I will now point out, through an exact analysis of the images that entirely carry this poem, the different views of love. I especially would like to elaborate on the mode of action of the images (Wirkungsweise?!?!) and the reasons for the fears of people who don't believe in love anymore.
Structure and title
The poem is composed of six stanzas of four lines each and can be divided into three sub-units, each of them containing two stanzas.
The first conclusions of the poem’s content can immediately be drawn from its title. The rose is a very common symbol of love, and in the run of the poem it will become obviously clear that the rose is to be equated with love here.
The first unit
The first unit of the poem directly takes up the motif of love. Here the orator, who is first person singular, compares the quite pessimistic opinion of love of the others represented by “some” (lines 1, 3, 5) and later by “you” (line 8) to his much more optimistic and hopeful view.
The accumulation of negative arguments is stressed by the extremely striking use of the combination of anaphoras, parallelisms and the rhyme schemata. In lines one to four the speaker describes how the others see love. He says that some see love as “a river, that drowns the tender reed” (ll. 1-2) and as “a razor, that leaves [the] soul to bleed” (ll.3-4). These two metaphors which are linked through the utilization of parallelisms and anaphoras (lines one and three, the other in lines two and four) and the rhyme in lines two and four illustrate the fear of these people in a very urgent way, because a rapid river, just as a razor, can hurt or even cause death.
The very violent imagery of the river which drowns the tender reed shows that even love is able to drown something, and to carry someone away with it.
Sometimes, people jump into a relationship without really knowing each other first. One of them adapts his/her lifestyle too much to that of his potential lover without really being ready for a relationship, or they may speak too quickly about strong feelings for each other. Then they will perhaps have to realize in the end, that love, nearness and affection were only an illusion and wishful thinking.
But, even worse is when one of the lovers has developed deep feelings for his partner during this time. The other person, however, noticed that their own feelings were not of the same intensity, and were only for a very short, even though intensive, period. Often such unanswered feelings lead into a crisis, perhaps even depression. Sometimes there are people who feel uprooted and unloved after such a split, and so filled with self-doubt and hurt feelings that they are afraid of getting involved with another person again. They fear that a new relationship could possibly take the same course and the same wounds would be inflicted upon their hearts again. A very famous saying says: “Who loves, is easy to hurt”. This is exactly what is meant by the tender reed - a person that loves another person is, to a certain extent, dependent on this person and at her mercy because when you love someone he has the ability to hurt you very badly.
The metaphor of “the razor that leaves [the] soul to bleed” (ll.3-4) refers to exactly these wounds and works according to the same schemata. Love is described here as a very hard and sharp tool that is able to cause deep flesh wounds and which is sometimes misused for self-abuse, a silent cry for help of people who do not know how to go on with life, who have fears with which they can’t cope, perhaps, even are not able to feel that they are alive.
This image of the razor, which is closely related to that one of the rapid as well in its message as in its syntax (parallelism, anaphora), is to show again how much love can hurt and how serious the wounds of it can be. The soul (l.4) stands here for the whole person (pars pro toto) or, spoken in a more romantic way, for the heart. The heart, like the rose, is a very common symbol of love and it has become common to think of the heart as the home of the soul, of love and feelings. Biologically seen is the heart one of the most important organs of a human being and it would in, all probability, mean a person's death, if the heart was harmed. This means that it could be a person’s physical or even mental death if he/she was hurt by love in such a violent way.
Furthermore, the idea of misuse of a razor raises the question of whether love could be some kind of self-abuse. People who scratch themselves usually feel good while they hurt themselves with a razor - they find an outlet in this action and feel alive while they scratch their body and see the blood, but then, after a while, things are worse then before. They did not help them to escape reality - their escape was only temporary and after the kick they got out of cutting themselves, the problems are even worse and what remains are the wounds and in the long run the scars. So these people may see love as some sort of self-abuse, an action with which to find a way out of reality, fears and pain; a state which seems to be pleasant stunning and comforting for a short time, but when it is over the situation became worse than before and what remains are the scars on their soul, which will never fade completely.
The second stanza is connected with the preceding one by the continued use of anaphora, parallelism and by the retained motive of danger.
Here the opinion of “some” is again represented in the form of the parallelism (some say love it is a hunger, line 5) but then in the second part of the parallelism there is a very important turning point because here the narrator for the first time, presents his opinion (ll.7/8; I say love it is a flower, and you its only seed) in contrast to the view of “some”.
The metaphor of hunger in this stanza works according to the same principle as that of the river and the razor and also illustrates that love can harm a person.
In this image, love is compared with hunger which is a basic need in order to show that one can hunger for love as well as one can hunger for food and that it makes no difference if this hunger is physical or psychological.
SEHNSUCHT
The fact that in the world there are millions of people who die because they do not have enough to eat and every child knows that a being has to eat if it wants to stay alive is to prove how serious and elementary this hunger of love to this people is and that they think every being is damned to die sooner or later if it does not get enough love.
Furthermore, the hopelessness of the people becomes quiet clear in this metaphor because here it says that they believe that this hunger is “endless and aching”. Especially the expression “endless” makes the reader feel that these people really do not seem to have kept any hope and do not believe in better times to come. The use of “aching” is in my opinion used in order to stress, that this mental hurt even affected to their body.
The orators view of love
After this representation of the others’ view of love a great “BUT” seems to follow and the orator tells about his own attitude towards love, which marks a very important turning point of the poem.
He claims that love is a flower (l. 7) and that the people are its only seed (l.8). By the utilization of this metaphor he tries to give them hope and show them that love is not as cruel as they think. He claims that it is, instead, a very beautiful plant which can grow out of them, and only out of them, because there is no other seed. Due to the fact that the author, in this third line of the second stanza, still keeps the parallelism but gets rid of the anaphora by replacing “some” against “I” he stresses the discrepancy between these two contradictory opinions. It also indicates that he will not change his opinion and stop believing in love.
Furthermore in this line he uses the direct address “you” instead of “some” for the first time in order to involve the audience more forcefully.
The second unit
After introducing the two quite different views of love in the first unit, in the second one the speaker tries to show the people that there will indeed be no fulfilling love for them unless they radically change their way of acting and thinking. In this unit he directly names the various ways of fearful acting and thinking which lead to the point where one can neither receive nor give any love. By the use of many personifications (three of the four reasons given in the third and fourth stanza work with the help of it) the orator tries to show the people in a very urgent way, what exactly they did or still do wrong.
By the means of these examples he tries to make it clear to the people why they are scared and to encourage them to lose these fears and to dare something.
Firstly the orator states the personification of the “heart afraid of breaking” (l. 9), that never learns to dance (l.10). This personification says that those people who are afraid that something could happen to their heart will never love a person so deeply that their heart joyfully in such a fast way that it would nearly start to dance or even give them a heart attack (?????).
In its more figurative and true sense of the word, it says that a person must not be afraid of hurt if he/she really wants to live. Of course one would in, all probability, never be hurt if he never dared anything, but one would also never be able to enjoy and to live. In addition to that, it would be a life full of doubts and fears in which one would never be able to realize his dreams. The following causes are very similar to this first one.
The second personification refers to those very dreams (It’s the dream afraid of waking that never takes the chance, ll.11/12) and is, through its semantics as well as its syntax, connected to the first personification, which serves to show how varied these fears are. This personification appeals to people to fight for their dreams and not to resign because those dreams may appear as inaccessible or hard to reach. It tells people, just as two famous sayings do, to live their dreams and not just to dream their lives, because one who fights can lose, but one who gave up has already lost.
The next stanza is by a further reason connected to the former one but now the order of reason and from this reason resulting consequence (The heart is afraid of breaking and will because of this reason never learn to dance, the dream is afraid waking and will therefore never take the chance…) is altered in order to keep the number of syllables in the poem.
The orator starts this stanza with a statement that does not really need to be analyzed because its message is quite clear.
The statement is that “the one who cannot seem to give” (l.14) won’t be taken (l.13) which means that one must be willing to give something and to accept his person opposite with all her major and minor mistakes if oneself wants to be taken which is an integral fact of love.
The second reason given in this stanza is again a personification and carries more content which can be analyzed.
The orator here claims that the soul which is afraid of dying will never learn to live (ll.15/16).
This statement is closely related to a statement of the bible which contains the order to intrepid creed. (???! furchtlosem Glaubensbekenntnis)
Matthew 10:39 says:
“39Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.”
His further verses all together contain nearly the same content which meaning is that the people must not be scared. Matthew calls upon mankind to believe in god and his love, he tells them to believe in God and not to fear the consequences of their belief as well as the poem calls upon the people to lose their fear and to believe in love.
As well as the heart (l.9), the soul represents the feelings of a being which are equated with the being itself here but is in contrast to this completely non physical. The soul does not need a worldly body because she does only exist of feelings or a material, which we human beings are not able to understand. And this fact, that mankind is not able to comprehend what this material could be, where to the soul will go after death and that the soul might perhaps be eternal, makes us human beings to consider it as something that is to a certain extend divine or at least nearer to something, which is divine and out of our reach. In view of these reasons and the preceding lines by Matthew I would say, that the orator to a certain extend canonizes love.
By these mentioned causes the orator tries to prove the that the people are afraid of committing themselves because they are afraid of being hurt but that they have to lose these fears if they really want to live (l.16), dance (l. 10), being taken (l. 13) and when they want to be able to take the chance. (l. 12)
The second unit is closed by the parallelism “that never learns to live” (l. 16) which has got the same syntax as the last line of the preceding stanza (that never takes the chance, l. 12)
The third unit
The third unit contrasts with the first and the second one because here the poetic stops comparing his opinion with the one of the others and to give them the reasons for their, what he believes, wrong attitude towards love.
The third unit solely pursues the aim to encourage the people not to give up hope for better times to come and not to stop believing in love.
The first two lines of this last unit are linked by the use of anaphora and parallelism and contain the same message.
The orator says here “and the night has been too lonely (l. 17) and the road has been too long” (l.18) in order to show that he understands how hard life for these people must have been in the last time and that he knows, what they must have been suffered.
The image of the lonely night associates darkness, cold and loneliness. Many people are afraid of being alone at night outdoors (or even indoors!) because they fear the dark and the fact, that they cannot see the dangers, which might lurk in this dark. And even if there is no danger, darkness often plays tricks on human beings because of their fantasy that makes them see the various threats. These people might not see these imaginative threats anymore, if there was someone by their side, someone, who would try to fight against their fears and who would give them support and safety.
And in addition to that they would in all probability be able to lose their fears for the real existing dangers, too, if this someone was a person in whom they could completely trust and from whom they would know, that he would never ever let them down and who would always try everything to protect them.
So all in all this image is to underline, how lonely these people were and how much they were on their fear’s mercy, because there was nobody to lean on, a person, who went through the dark times with them. Furthermore it could also show that a relationship can only last, when there is total trust in the partner.
The image of the road, which has been to long (l. 18) stresses, that these times of fear and loneliness lasted on much too long and that it was hard to survive these times, which sapped their energy as well as they sapped their belief in love and their hope for better times.
The next two lines do again start with “and” which stresses, how many things made this time a hard time. The orator supposes here, that the people now “think that love is only for the lucky and the strong” (ll. 19/20). Looking at the past, this would mean, that there would probably never be a further chance for a fulfilling love for these people again because they became weak during the time of the “lonely night” (l. 17). I think that these people saw a lot of happy couples, in which the partners seemed to be very strong but that they perhaps did not realize, that these happiness and strength did also not exist from the very beginning. These relationships also had to develop and these people had to go through very hard times,too, before they found each other and it was a long way and hard work, to built up a relationship, in which both were able to be happy and strong.
Of course it is true that a person that is strong, happy and self-confident is more attractive than a weak person, who only lives in fear and thinks, that there will never be a person, that will truly love him/her but this is the point, which the orator tries to explain in the whole poem. He encourages the people to lose their fears in order to become such a person, that can be loved. So these lines stress again, that it depends on the people themselves, if there will be loved anytime and that it lies in their own responsibility mainly and does not depend on a relationship, whether they become strong or not.
In contrast to the preceding units the two stanzas of the last unit are syntactically and partly semantically not connected to each other.
This serves to put emphasis on the discrepancy, what these people think on the one hand and the hope the orator tries to give them on the other hand, through which a great “BUT” again seems to seperate these two stanzas and by this the two different attitudes.
Furthermore all four lines of this last stanza belong together whereas in the preceding ones it were maximum two that did not make any sense without each other.
These last four lines which are full of metaphorical words, are the part of the poem, in which the intention of the orator to encourage the people becomes mostly clear. The orator appeals to his audience to “remember in the winter (l. 21) “far beneath the bitter snow” (l. 22), that there “lies the seed that with the sun’s love” (l. 23) “in the spring, becomes a rose” (l.24).
The winter here again stands as well as the “lonely night” for the lonely, cold and hard times, which one had to suffer but everybody knows, that there will be a new morning after the night as well as there will be a new spring after the winter again.
It is common to speak about the winter and even the autumn as the seasons of fading life and dead, but it is also common to think that a being that survived the hard winter and succeeded in reaching the next spring will receive new energies and joy of life out of this.
The snow here is to be equated with the bad experiences and the self-isolation that resulted from this experiences of those people, who were badly hurt. This cool surface protects them from new wounds, until they digested it to a sufficient extend as well as the snow protects the seed from the frost. This bitter snow will thaw with the sun’s love in the spring as well as the self-isolation will fade, when the hurt person finishes with the past and gets to know a person, in whom he/she can totally trust and who gives him/her all his/her warmth and love.
The fact that a grain generally contains nearly the whole material which is needed to become a rose serves to show, that everybody of us carries the possibility in himself to become such a rose, a person that grows in the love to another person.
The only difficulty is that we in contrast to the seed are able to melt this snow, which represents our self-isolation.
We alone have to do this, we have to overcome things which happened but which we cannot change after the event if we want to be loved again.
For a person can love one as much as he/she wants, when this person is not ready for this it will not succeed, as well as the sunbeams will never reach the seed, if the snow surface is to thick.
It is important to have line 23 and 24 of the poem to understand line 21 and 22 as well as it is important to know, that this temporary self-isolation helps one to get ready for a new love, that will surely come, when one survived the hard times.
[/the][/the][/d][/ir][/']